Serendip is an independent site partnering with faculty at multiple colleges and universities around the world. Happy exploring!
The Story of Evolution and the Evolution of Stories: EvoLit
Welcome to The Story of Evolution and the Evolution of Stories, offered in Spring 2011 @ Bryn Mawr College. This is an interestingly different kind of place for writing, and may take some getting used to. The first thing to keep in mind is that this is not a place for "formal writing" or "finished thoughts." It's a place for thoughts-in-progress, for what you're thinking (whether you know it or not) on your way to what you think next. Imagine that you're not worrying about "writing" but instead that you're just talking to some people you've met. This is a "conversation" place, a place to find out what you're thinking yourself, and what other people are thinking, so you can help them think and they can help you think. The idea is that your "thoughts in progress" can help others with their thinking, and theirs can help you with yours.
We're glad you're here, and hope you'll come both to enjoy and value our shared imagining of the future evolution of ourselves as individuals and of our gendered, scientific, technological world. Feel free to comment on any post below, or to POST YOUR THOUGHTS HERE....
week 1
While reading On the Origin of Species, I could not shake Professor Grobstein's directive to us to read it as we would a romance, or any other novel. I felt so little of the words on the page held romance in and of themselves, that, instead, the true romance was somewhat hidden beneath the work, hinted at by Darwin's throwaway comments about his research, life, and contemporaries. Every so often his pure joy for his subject would come tumbling out: "We see these beautiful co-adaptations most plainly in the woodpecker and missletoe [sic]; and only a little less plainly... in the plumed seed which is wafted by the gentlest breeze; in short, we see beautiful adaptations everywhere and in every part of the organic world" (p132).
Week 1 Thoughts - Creativity and Finding Common Ground
Only one week in and a garden of new thoughts are germinating already! One of the paths I’m curious about is the role of evolution in determining what is POPULAR (the areas where we find agreement) in terms of literature or music or art etc. We discussed how our diverse perspectives influence how we approach the summaries of our observations of life, where is that place where we come together? Why do we agree? How do we get there? How does “selection” work when it’s a matter of creativity as opposed to literal survival? Given that the universe is so large and constantly expanding, it would follow that there are infinite possibilities in terms of creativity. Why don’t we enjoy and pursue them all equally?
Science used for Public Policy
In class on Thursday, we discussed how uncertainty is a large part of the scientific process. Often times experiments result in more questions than answers, which leads to more exploration. Creativity and different viewpoints are crucial for approaching problems and seeking a more complete understanding of a question. These are many positive outcomes of the uncertainty of science. The negative aspect to uncertainty is when science is used to make public policy. If these observations and beliefs aren’t certain, when is there enough evidence to be used to dictate what people can and can’t do? If the evidence can yield different interpretations, what makes one interpretation more valuable than another?
Thoughts on Week 1
Based on my education on the topic of evolution, I have been taught to believe that evolution is exclusively applied to organisms. Darwin's observations and conclusions coupled with Mendel's genetic experiments on living organisms told me that evolution is "survival of the fittest", "natural selection" and that the inheritance of these fit traits are guided by a set of rules and probability. After this first week of class, I found myself thinking too close-minded about this topic. At it's core, evolution is about perpetual changing so the term can generally encompass anything that changes over time such as language and culture. Because my education has always tagged evolution to biology and the Darwinian concepts, my thoughts have been biased.
"Evolution is a Bloody Good Story"
In class, Professor Grobstein asked the class, "Why am I here? Or rather, Why are you here?" And the first word or phrase that came to my mind was "chain-reaction." Darwin, in his novel "Origin of Species," says that, "We have.. seen that it is the most flourishing and dominant species of the larger genera, which on average vary most; and varieties, as we shall hereafter see, tend to become converted into new distinct species." He then in a later chapter asks how have these adaptations from organisms been perfected. I believe that chance has a lot to do with how we got here and how other organisms became what we now know them as, which correlates to my previous chain-reaction thought.
Week 1: Science, Literature, and Change
“The truth about stories is that that's all we are ... The Nigerian storyteller Ben Okri says that .... 'if we change the stories we live by, quite possibly we change our lives.’ ....”
—Thomas King, The Truth About Stories
Post for Week 1: Thoughts on discussion
Our discussions of evolution and stories have really captivated me. The concept of truth being absent from science is a new one for me. I had always accepted that science was about facts, concrete details that were definable and correct about the universe. This new perception of science is a little mind-boggling for me. I'm fascinated by the idea that science only disproves theories, that evolution itself is only another story. If science is truly furthered by disproving ideas, then it seems to me that the failure of a theory is really a success for scientific exploration. I think there's also a connection between this scientific exploration and evolution.
Writing as Evolution
"She's still alive, my invented friend, just as I conceved here, still uncrushed by the need for happier endings. All writing is rewriting" .... Richard Powers, Generosity, Picador, 2010
Introductions
Hi, I'm Mindy. I'm a sophomore here at BMC and I am a Near Eastern Archaeology major. I don't know much about literature, just what I've read personally. I have no formal training in writing really, but I am a professionally produced playwright. I've always loved biology, so the combo of writing and biology seemed like the perfect class for me. Questions:
1. I would really like to see how a "literature" class works, I am curious to see how other people approach writing.
2.I'm also interested to see how people contemplate difficult questions.
3. How are we going to approach Darwin? He himself is such a controversial person and topic.
Me, Myself and I
Hi,
My name is Kerlyne. I am a Senior Anthropology major and Biology minor at Bryn Mawr College. I have taken previous classes on Evolution in my time here at Bryn Mawr but this class interested me very much in my last semester because it seems to focus on the "story" of evolution. The idea that this may not be set in stone and may change at any moment. I enjoy the notion that one should not take everything as fact and instead, our everyday lives should revolve around collecting observations and making possible stories that serve as explanations. Many of these "stories" seem to have been created solely to find comfort in what is often unknown. I hope to get a greater insight on how stories play a role in science and our everyday lives.
hi
Hello everyone. My name is Hope, I'm a senior Biology Major. I went to one of those high schools in GA that had to put stickers in the biology textbooks saying evolution is only one of many theories or something. It was a big controversy and on the news all the time for a while. I also have a fish named Bruce and I want to live on a boat.
Hello!
Hi, my name is Katie and I’m a sophomore at Bryn Mawr. I’m an anthropology major with a biology minor, and have a particular interest in evolution and primatology. I’m excited for this class because I’m hoping it will incorporate both the cultural and biological aspects of anthropology by bringing to light how culture impacts evolution. The writing and the sharing of our ideas is a huge part of our culture, and the evolution of our culture has been crucial to the evolution of our species on a genetic level. As a result, our evolution is not only caused by how the environment changes us, but how we change our environment.
Introduction
I'm a senior comparative literature major at Haverford, but I like science if it's explained slowly and clearly. I like trying new foods and listening to podcasts so I'm not really sure what I want to be when I grow up. I liked "The Plague."
Introduction
Hello! My name is Kati Zaylor, and I am new to Serendip, Professor Grobstein, and Professor Dalke. Therefore I am excited and intrigued about this course and learning more about evolution, biology, and literature. I am a senior and a Theater major, and so I approach this course with a relatively open mind about the way the universe operates. Because I don't understand most science, I am not constrained within the limits of what is and what isn't, and feel as though there are many possibilities and unknowns to the universe. I respect some limits of science, but I will continue to verbally oppose trying to define the undefinable and declaring what is or isn't at times when humans have no place to do so. For example, "The universe doesn't evolve.
Hello
Hi,
My name is Ashley and I'm a junior at Bryn Mawr. I'm a sociology major and an education minor, my goal is - and has been for as long as I can remember - to teach at the elementary level. I adore kids and love working with them. Currently I work at a pre-school and have had various field placements throughout Philadelphia elementary schools, last semester having worked with 5th graders. I'm also a community fellow for the PhillyGoes2College initiative being run out of the mayor's office of education, whose aim is to get a higher percentage of Philly high school students to college. Through the program we provide services, such as writing workshops, to these students at no cost. Though I aim to teach elementary students, I enjoy working with students in many capacities.
Introduction
Hi! My name is Carson and I'm a freshman at Haverford. I'm planning to double major in biology and English (assuming all of the classes fit into my schedule!), while fulfilling pre-med requirements. My goal is to become a pediatric oncologist. Outside of school I also run track at Haverford, work in the school's career development office and founded an organization that makes hats and blankets for children who have cancer. I'm looking forward to combining aspects of my two majors in a new and interesting way in this class, and engaging in discussions both online and in class to gain new perspectives on the topics from my peers.
Self-Intro
Hi, I'm Rachel and I am pre-vet here at Bryn Mawr- bio major, NBS concentration. This is my 3rd class with Anne and Paul is my major advisor, so I guess I'm interested to see how the class flows between both of them. I also really like posting my papers and class thoughts on serendip and I am a big fan of mixing different medias in my papers, so I am glad to be back using it. As I said in class I never really learned about evolution; I learned about the historical figures central to it in history classes but I never quite made it to evolution itself.
A Little About Me
Hi my name is Namratha and i'm a sophomore at Bryn Mawr. I'm a political science and economics double major with a minor in international relations with a concentration in peace and conflict studies. My larger goals in life are to pursue international human rights law and possibly writing. I also love dancing (indian classical), music, and russian literature. On campus I'm part of SAW (south asian women) and the pre-law society. What I'm looking forward to in this class is using nontraditional mediums in an academic environment. I hope that I can participate in some meaningful discussions and learn to see things from a different perspective!
A Little About Me
Hi my name is Namratha and i'm a sophomore at Bryn Mawr. I'm a political science and economics double major with a minor in international relations with a concentration in peace and conflict studies. My larger goals in life are to pursue international human rights law and possibly writing. I also love dancing (indian classical), music, and russian literature. On campus I'm part of SAW (south asian women) and the pre-law society. What I'm looking forward to in this class is using nontraditional mediums in an academic environment. I hope that I can participate in some meaningful discussions and learn to see things from a different perspective!
A Little About Me
Hi my name is Namratha and i'm a sophomore at Bryn Mawr. I'm a political science and economics double major with a minor in international relations with a concentration in peace and conflict studies. My larger goals in life are to pursue international human rights law and possibly writing. I also love dancing (indian classical), music, and russian literature. On campus I'm part of SAW (south asian women) and the pre-law society. What I'm looking forward to in this class is using nontraditional mediums in an academic environment. I hope that I can participate in some meaningful discussions and learn to see things from a different perspective!