Serendip is an independent site partnering with faculty at multiple colleges and universities around the world. Happy exploring!

Literary Kinds

Syndicate content
Anne Dalke's picture
Anne Dalke's picture

Performing Literary Kinds

Dear literary kinds--
Here's the plan for Thursday's performances. We appear to have 8 groups; since class is 80 minutes long, each group should plan to take no more than 10 minutes (if some take less that's fine). I'll be monitoring the time, and cut you off when yours is up, so you should practice ahead of time re: the time you'll take.
At this point the schedule is
jrlewis, aseidman
jrf, ShaynaS, spleenfiend
mkarol, xhan
rmeyers, teal, sbg90
Herbie, sweetp
nk0825, TPB1988
skindeep, aybala50, rachelr

Can't wait!
Anne

aybala50's picture

Labeling to Framing

I think it is very interesting that we started out the class talking about genre as a form of labeling and now we are talking about framing not only in genres, but in the world. Framing has come up as almost a necessity...this is how we see the world not only in literary work, but also in reality as well as dreams? Similar arguments were also brought up for labeling...is it a necessity? It makes life easier? 

aseidman's picture

House and Holmes

There's been some commentary about the formulaic nature of the House television show.

I'm reasonably certain (and this is backed up by a comment made by the creator of House, MD) that the House and Wilson relationship is based on the Holmes/Watson relationship from Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes stories.

Those stories were extremely formulaic, and there's a great deal of literary speculation that Conan Doyle didn't care too much about the plots of his mysteries. The formulaic nature of the stories was (theoretically) meant to highlight the nuances of the character development, and to takethe distracting nature of the plot away so that more focus could be placed on the characters.

Herbie's picture

Malpractice?

My problem with the "House's Brain/Wilson's Heart" 2-part episode is thus: not a single one of those doctors recused him or herself from that case.  In the real world, I'm pretty sure that's called "malpractice."  I know that Amber was unconscious, and I'm sure she trusted all of them implicitly.  However, there's a saying in law that a lawyer who represents himself has a fool for a client.  In medicine, where it is often much more emotional, it is absolutely unexcuseable that none of those doctors took themselves off the case, especially as each of them at one point or another realized they shouldn't be working on it.

nk0825's picture

House's trips to "Wonderland?"

 Watching House has been quite the experience. I think the thing that keeps me coming back as an avid viewer is that every case is different, even though the formula for most of the episodes is the same. I guess this shows that I like formulaic things, it makes me feel comfortable because I [sort of] know what to expect. After watching the episode "9-5" a few weeks back when it aired I felt jipped. It didn't follow the formula, it didn't even follow Dr. House! I felt like an addict who had finally realized her what her addiction was: a fascination with Gregory House [and the realization that I feel lost without the series formula!] I'm not so sure that my fixation is because I want him to change--I actually find him refreshing.

TPB1988's picture

A Not So Subtle Pattern

I have been watching House for many years but once I sat down to view the show for the class rather than pleasure I noticed a pattern in the episodes that is also seen in the series. Roughly every show begins with the patient performing a mundane everyday task and then suddenly some sort of seizure or abnormal activity occurs that leads the rest of the show to take place in the hospital.

xhan's picture

House-Private Lives

 As the title seems to highlight(Private Lives), the subject of privacy comes into play numerous times during this episode. What first caught my attention was Frankie's level of honesty/dishonesty. Frankie was perceived as someone who likes to post everything on a blog: good or bad, she wanted her readers to know. Yet it was later found, that the one thing that she did not post on her blog was her abnormal bowel movements. Her reasoning for that was "nobody wants to hear about that stuff", which contradicts what she said earlier in response to Taylor's request for her to refrain from posting about her personal life on her blog: "if i start picking and choosing, i'm being dishonest i'm sorry".

jrlewis's picture

An Odd Ending

I finally finished reading my translation of "The Arabian Nights."  My text did not include a closing of the story of Shahrazad and the king.  The final story within the frame was unusual in many ways.  "The Story of Jullanar of the Sea" contains four strong female characters that balance the power of the four male characters.  The plot is also atypical in that it has elements very similar to the frame story.  There is a powerful monarch who takes lovers for a limited amount of time and then permanently maims them.  However, in the story within the story, the gender roles are reversed; the woman is the powerful partner.  The male lover, the hero, is able to escape from her harm.  It is a happily after ending, not unlike the translator's note about

Herbie's picture

Class Notes, 4/22/10

First, let me apologize to anyone who wanted to use yesterday's class notes to write her paper today.  Sorry!

 

In yesterday's class, we first went over some administrative things, as well as referring back to previous discussions via quotations from guest speakers and other English department faculty.  Please look at those on the Class Notes from that day.

aybala50's picture

Class Notes- 4/20/2010

mkarol pointed out that these stories have attached to them pictures.

-       For Thursday’s class we are watching episode 14 of the current/6th season of House, M.D., which is about a blogger that gets sick. Her medical decisions are effected by the fact that she is a blogger.

Jessica Watkins's picture

House Parody

Here it is! As promised, MadTV's parody of House. It really highlights the formulaic qualities of the show--you really know when something has made it big when MadTV makes a parody of it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LcQsD0HU0SY

 

rmeyers's picture

the serial

When did it begin? A story that is told in bits and pieces, chronologically, unfolding piece by piece? We know where it has led --to the literary story magazines of early 1900s, to television series, to the 1001 Arabian Nights. Part of the fun of this story is how much is held back ("tune in next week for Batman's latest adventures!") and how much the audience is controlled by the dispensation. We talked about this a bit with graphic novels and audio-books, how much different platforms/media allow audience pacing and interaction. Television series provide this in an even more structured sense, giving the viewer very specific time slots in which to 'watch' the story unfold.

Shayna S's picture

Overarching Themes and Big Questions

 The huge theme of "Private Lives" was, well, about lives (and parts of lives) that were no longer private. Frankie blogged about everything, including her medical options. Her audience was permitted to know everything (almost) about her. In the end, it was something very personal that Frankie had not shared with anyone, online or not, that saved her life. House, on the other hand, was an unwanted voyeur in Wilson's past (and private) life, imitating Frankie in posting Wilson's secret throughout the hospital. On the other hand, when Wilson finds out that House is reading sermons written by his biological father, he keeps it to himself, privately discussing the matter with House rather than revenging himself  by announcing it publicly. 

rachelr's picture

Then vs. Now

 After my initial readings of the Thousand and One Nights where I skipped out of order I then went through and read the introduction through the Story of the Third Calendar, Son of a King of the ELF Lang translation. While I enjoyed the stories, I couldn't help but to compare my reading of them to what I remember of reading them as a child- I have only a collection of some of the stories and they were in miniature books in a box set. I'm sure that they were much more simplified than the translation that we are reading for class, but I remember being completely enthralled with the tales.

Herbie's picture

Where to draw the line?

While watching the "Privacy Matters" episode of House, I was first very excited to see Laura Prepon acting again, having not seen her in anything since I stopped watching "That '70s Show."  After that, I was frankly concerned with her character's behavior.  I frankly like her reasoning, that we as people behave better when we know we're being judged.  I think it's very much like one of the theoretical articles we read earlier this semester where the blogger altered his habits because he was blogging and sharing them with the internet.

spleenfiend's picture

public lives

Drawing a comparison between House and 1001 Nights feels really strange.  However, just like each story in 1001 Nights seems to function on its own but is in fact tied to the others, episodes of House have episodic "patient of the week" plots, but there are still ongoing plots related to the main characters, and those don't make as much sense of of context.

Anyway, I love House; it's probably the only non-cartoon/American television series I actually follow.  The main reason I like the show has to do with the dynamic of House and Wilson's relationship, and the character of House himself.

nk0825's picture

Framed Tales, Gregory House, and Aladdin

It was interesting for me as a House fan to take a step back from the series as a whole to digest the overwhelming thread throughout "Private Lives." To be honest, I have never really sat and tried to understand the connection between the title of the episode and the episode itself. I think this may be because I watch shows to relax and give my brain a rest. But, I realized how much I was missing, a lot of the little things, when I passively "watch" a show.

TPB1988's picture

Be Not Afraid of Privacy

After watching the “Private Lives” episode of House I began to really analyze privacy as a whole. From this episode I interpreted privacy as being similar to a very exclusive club and once one is married another member is added. The problem begins to arise when  the club goes from being exclusive to all inclusive when personal blogs are added to the mix. Frankie says in the episode that people behave badly when they think no one is watching and that she would not be honest if she chose which parts of her life to blog about. Choosing to end her privacy is her choice, but bringing her husband's life into the blog as well makes me question the boundaries of personal blogs.

TPB1988's picture

Second Selections

For my second time reading the short stories I wanted to go in consecutive order so I read The Story of Es-Sindibad of the Sea and Es-Sindibad of the Land, The First Voyage of Es-Sindibad of the Sea, and The Second Voyage of Es-Sindibad of the Sea. To read the stories I went to the Harvard classics website. I really enjoyed reading the stories one right after another this time because they made more sense that way. I don't think these stories were meant to be read out of order without have the prelude from the first story to set up the atmosphere.

skindeep's picture

story telling

for both the days, i read stories from the harvard classics. the first time, i jumped around and tried to get a general 'feel' of the storises - i read 'the story of jullanar of the sea', the story of nur-ed-din' and 'the story of the fisherman'.

it was only after reading the story of the fisherman that i realised that the other two stories were two or more stories in themselves. it didnt upset me though because despite the fact that it meant that i had read more, the first two stories left me feeling more complete, like i had accomplished more.. whereas in order to get the feel of the fisherman story i had to read ahead and see what happened, or atleast see how it unfolded.