Serendip is an independent site partnering with faculty at multiple colleges and universities around the world. Happy exploring!

Intersectionality of Identity

changing9's picture

While reading the first part of Exile and Pride by Eli Clare, the part that intrigued me the most was the way in which Clare discusses "exile". The manner in which Clare draws attention to the fact that she felt unsafe in her own home due to the sexual and physical abuse she suffered through, and the complexity in the term "home" were all beautifully written out in ways that state clearly that this text was not written to gather sympathy for a disabled queer individual, but to highlight the intersectionality of identity. 

Camphill Reflexion

Sunshine's picture

Camphill seems almost too good to be true. They have amazing food, napping stations, and everybody is extremely friendly. What more could we ask for? I’m not too worried about the portrait project. I feel like as long as everyone knows that they shouldn’t expect a masterpiece from me, I’ll be alright. I’m actually more interested in the work we’ll be doing when we’re not drawing. I’m looking forward to the opportunity of baking or weaving with the residents. So hopefully it is too good and true. 

 

Reflection on Camphill

nbarker's picture

I'm so much more excited for our trip to Camphill now that we have visited. Initially, my main expectation had been that it would be quite a bit larger than the reality--more people, and a different structure. My image of farming towns has always been, also, othat they are flat, not on hilly terrain such as that at Camphill! This is probably my midwestern upbringing talking, however...

Initial Reactions to Eli's Story

The Unknown's picture

I appreciated the way Eli Clare used the mountain as a metaphor of the different struggles people face depending on their abilities. She declared that we are taught to assume that people at the bottom of the mountain did not work hard enough, but she explains that they were presented with different opportunities and therefore reached different heights. I appreciated what she said about it being difficult for newcomers to climb the mountain, because all that lies ahead is scary, new, and different from all previous experiences.

In-Person Relationships

smalina's picture

Like Bridget, I felt immensely reassured by our visit to Camphill, primarily because we have been talking for so long about a large project that relies entirely on a relationship with an ambiguous "camper." Knowing only that drawing is necessary and that we will be spending four days in a new environment, it was easy to be intimidated by the skills we assumed were necessary. However, visiting Camphill, I realized that all it really comes down to is a human relationship between two people.

Respect

Leigh Alexander's picture

Like Weilla wrote in her post, I too am astonished at Eli Clare's accomplishments, given his hardships, and the interesting perspectives he provides given the struggles that he faced through his childhood and adolescence.  First off, he wrote a memoir which in itself is an accomplishment.  I feel like so many people assert that they’re going to write a memoir and have children, or get a job or a dog or something and never get around to it.  On page 20 he writes, “For years I have wanted to write this story…” and he did.

Reflection on Exile and Pride

wwu2's picture

At first, I thought Clare is advocating the idea of protecting the environment. However, as further I read, I was amazed by the amount of information that Eli Clare compact in these chapters. She connects and criticizes from various aspects— class, race, gender, the environment— which is really compelling and powerful. Other than letting the surroundings to shape who she is, she disrupts our normal thinking patterns and reflects on how she has changed the world. It makes me rethink of myself: have I ever influenced other people’s life?

Reflection on Camphill

ndifrank's picture

I am in complete of awe of camphill. Mimi was so inviting and you can really sense the close relationships formed between the co workers and villagers. The co op lifestye really intrigued me.What surprised me was how rural the camp truly was and how the Camphill manages finances. The shared car and small salary that Mimi recieves shocked being that I have never expperienced a lifestlye relative to hers. Mimi's life is Camphill and it as if she is not a seperate being. The architecture of the buildings even furthered the sense of the community melding into it's enviornments. I am truly excited to expand my painting and drawing skills ( or gain skills as a whole) at Camphill. It was so peaceful and inviting.

Naming.

Hgraves's picture

I feel as though the title that Ally chose, Respectable Eli, is very fitting for the author. Throughout part 1 of the book, even with the issues surrounding Clare's environment back at home, I never felt like the author was trying to gain pity from me. Normally when I read things regarding the environment, I feel as though the purpose of the text is to not only be informative but more so the sole purpose is to make the reader feel guilty about not doing anything to help.

He sounds cool

aquato's picture

I agree that part 1, when compared to the preface, is a shockingly different feel from what I was expecting. 20 pages into it, I had to stop and remember what I was supposed to be reading. I had figured that it was going to be more about Clare's disability, since his story with the mountain worked best with that struggle. I was confused when it shifted to environmental issues, but I went with it. I'd like to believe that his discussion about the detriment of clearcutting on salmon population can have a broader meaning.