Serendip is an independent site partnering with faculty at multiple colleges and universities around the world. Happy exploring!

Response to wwu2

gmchung's picture

I love your topic of your paper. Ozeki mentions a lot about GMOs and I really like the route you are taking. You might want to further think about what exactly is the art of nature? Maybe you might want to connect your last quote about diversity to the world as a whole (ex: different races). I like that you are comparing both sides; however, you might want to keep an open mind to as why farmers decide to plant GMOs instead have a set viewpoint that GMOs are bad. All in all, I really like the direction your paper is taking. Keep it up!

Response to mpatney

gmchung's picture

I love how you relate Yumi to Lloyd's potato! You might want to find examples in the text that you can use to support the argument of Lloyd treating Yumi as his potato. You also might want to find an example that supports how Yumi's role as a potato is transfered over to Cass. 

Response to winterprincess

Sydney's picture

Virushi, I think that the idea of your thesis can be supported easily. If you go into detail with this quote, then I think you could find some good support: ‘You know. You were there. I got knocked up by Elliot. I had an abortion. Lloyd hit me…’ (p.241)

I like that your first and third quotes are kind of opposites of each other. In the first, Yumi feels different and isolated. In the third, it’s Cass who feels that way.

Also, I like your second quote, but I don’t necessarily see how it supports the thesis. Hopefully tomorrow we can help you figure out how you can work it into your paper.

 

Response to Sherry

Sydney's picture

 

Sherry, I really like all of your quote selections. I can see the parallels; however, I’m think that you could make the connections more clear. I think we’re getting back in our groups tomorrow, so hopefully we can help you a bit more because I think that you have some really great ideas forming.

Impressions and Suggestions

R_Massey's picture

In response to Hgraves essay draft, I find it particularly interesting to view the characters as all elements in Yumi's life. It would seem that much of the novel is centered around Yumi's life and life choices and therefore a relevant claim. I think it would be interesting to see the claim that Yumi was not a bad seed, due to not being bad growing up, clarified further. Specifically, delving into what classifies as a "good seed" in the environment that Yumi grows up in and how she fits that.

response to Humans and Nature through Memory and Encoding

ally's picture

The passage wrote about the connection between plant and human. From Lloyd’s words, they discovered the strong and supportive bond between Momoko and plants. They stated the definition of the word “memory” and analyzed the process of forming, recalling memory, elaborating the how plants supports Momoko.

Furthermore, the passage is related to the “contact zone”, digging deeper into the relationship between plants and human, like peas and farmers, how they support and affect each other.

Body Image Conversation

Sunshine's picture

We want to focus on body image and the health center. Keeping in mind the techniques of monsoon and benaifer, the health center and the students will talk one on one. Meaning that members of the health center will get to share their experience as much as the students.

Response to WhoAmI

zara's picture

WhoAmI: I think the connection to the potatoes is a really interesting idea: that the potatoes are almost a metaphor for Yumi herself because they both undergo the same growth processes led by the same person. Further, the idea that identity is shaped by our surroundings, rather than our environment, can be an interesting, although somewhat small, distinction.

The claim is that our identity is based on our environment. 

Responses to Connectivity/Oedipal Conflict

aquato's picture

(3 striking ideas/comments/questions & aim at the claim)

OK so for zara's—

  1. Good idea looking up the definition of environment!! Maybe look into the etymology to see if that talks about people-to-people interactions, too?
  2. The difference of Cass/Yumi is a cool route to go. Would you be focusing on their "environments" growing up? With each other?
  3. The fact that all the people Yumi is "bound" to are adults (are we only shaped by authority figures, maybe??)
  4. (Claim) People make up our environments, and interactions with them (whether small or not) shapes our identities.

& for WhoAmI's—

response of Bad Seed and Cass, Under the Spotlight

weilla yuan's picture

Even though Haddiyah's paper is not fully uploaded, there are already some really interesting ideas. She looked up the etymology of bad seed and found out that the bad seed is not turned bad but is born bad. So Yumi is not a "bad seed" but is a good seed that did not get flurished during her childhood. 

She also argues that the bad influences (weed) that affect Yumi is Mr. Rhodes, the teacher who got into both her mind and body. and the other weed is her parents. after Yumi ran away, she barely heard from her parents, so it is hard to stay in touch with them.