Serendip is an independent site partnering with faculty at multiple colleges and universities around the world. Happy exploring!

respectable Eli

respectable Eli

ally's picture

When reading the first chapter – mountains, describing the tough times the writer had, all the disabilities and sexual abuse, I thought the topic of the book would focus on the difficulties the writer had gone through and the process of gaining self-respect. However, starting to read the first part, I doubt that I was reading another person’s story, totally different from the previous content. It has nothing to do with disability or trauma, in contrast, it is the scene of writer walking home after school looking at the trucks carrying loggings and enjoying the natural forest in her homeland. Throughout part1, the writer seldom mentioned about her sufferings. Although she didn’t put emphasis on her sufferings, combining the background and the story, she gained respect from me, not just because of her disabilities, but more importantly because of her deep and clear perception, her courage to stand out as a lesbian and fight for homosexuals.

 

The writer has no shame on herself, since she never hides from her miserable experience in childhood and her identity as a queer, and neither did she lived in the shadow of those hurts. She didn’t feel pity for herself, instead, she ignored her defect and took on the responsibility as a conscientious citizen. Sharing her youth experience with readers, she also stood out for the loggers on a fair position and condemned those innocent environmentalists that blame the environmental destruction on the loggers and the interest-driven capitalist. Moreover, she also talked about the subtle balance between human and nature. As a person who grown up in forest and now lives in urban areas, she has a more comprehensive understanding of the ‘clearcut’ issue.

Clarifying

 

Supporting

I feel as though the title that Ally chose, Respectable Eli, is very fitting for the author. Throughout part 1 of the book, even with the issues surrounding Clare's environment back at home, I never felt like the author was trying to gain pity from me. Normally when I read things regarding the environment, I feel as though the purpose of the text is to not only be informative but more so the sole purpose is to make the reader feel guilty about not doing anything to help.

Complexifying

 

Weaving

 

Challenging

 

Unspecified