This paper reflects the research and thoughts of a student at the time the paper was written for a course at Bryn Mawr College. Like other materials on Serendip, it is not intended to be "authoritative" but rather to help others further develop their own explorations. Web links were active as of the time the paper was posted but are not updated.
2006 Book Commentaries
I've always been interested in music. I've been singing since I was seven
and playing cello and piano since I was eight. It always fascinated me that my
orchestra could make people cry, smile, or just plain think all by playing different
kinds of music. In this book, Jourdain sheds light on the reasons that music
affects people, all the while making it accessible to absolutely anyone. Through
the use of diagrams and anecdotes, Jourdain takes a highly scientific topic and
makes it understandable to non-scientists, while still keeping the writings
intellectual. Anyone who has ever tried to do this knows that this is no small feat.
Jourdain really knows how to capture an audience. When he uses
examples, he chooses things that most people would know, or at least have
heard of. For instance, he uses the Pink Panther theme as his main musical
example. Correct me if I am wrong, but I think it is a fairly safe assumption that
most people have heard of the Pink Panther in some capacity. This theme also
makes for good, easy interpretation, as Jourdain describes the panther sneaking
around, and shows how one comes to understand this in the given music.
Jourdain makes many points about ways music can affect certain people.
For instance, some victims of brain damage can only move when they hear
music. I find it absolutely fascinating that music an set action potentials in
motion, and by doing so, take the place of the damaged piece of the victim's
brain that initiates motion. He also tells the story of a poor, blind, dumb slave boy
with a special talent—he could absorb a piece on a singe hearing, and then play
it perfectly. Jourdain brings these people to life, making understanding almost
Jourdain also makes use of anecdotes. He uses ones from real life, such
as that of Rosemary Brown, a psychic who claims to take dictation from long-
dead composers. He also uses imaginative stories, such as that of the Phyxians,
in chapter nine, who discover the probe Voyager 2. Through skillful segues,
Jourdain connects the stories to real science, explaining how people understand
music, and how music affects them.
In the course, I would have liked to hear more about music. It is such a
powerful tool that can be used with any person capable of hearing it to evoke a
desired response, though responses might not be the same for everyone. I
would love to understand more about exactly why that works, although this book
was very helpful. Music is universal. There is no one who does not listen to it.
This, I think, is what makes it such a powerful communicative device, and so
I always knew music could affect people, but I feel much better having an
understanding of how it works. I feel it would make a very interesting topic of
| Course Home | Serendip Home |